Letter 41: PELAGIUS IOHANNI DEFENSORI.
Pelagius to John the defensor [a papal estate-agent and legal officer].
Since Secundus, bishop of the city of Tauromenium [Taormina, on the eastern coast of Sicily], relying not on the innocence of his own actions but rather cast down by the obstinacy of a proud mind, behold, now that by God's favor nearly three years have passed since we took up, though unworthy, yet by the bounty and favor of God, the care of the apostolic see, has not even thought it worth learning whether we are alive, but, occupied with the lawsuits and affairs that suit his own purposes, with the rein of shame let slack believes that he may wander about, to such a degree that he is hardly ever to be found in his own church;
therefore let your experience by all means forbid him the use of the pallium [the woolen vestment of episcopal office], and, moreover, after the holy day of Easter, compel him by suitable enforcement to present himself before our gaze, so that, by a fitting censure, he may come to know the discipline which he has hitherto despised, not only for his own amendment but also for that of others.
AI-assisted translation - This translation was produced with AI assistance and has not been peer-reviewed. See the 19th-century translation or original Latin/Greek below for scholarly use.
Latin / Greek Original
PELAGIUS IOHANNI DEFENSORI. Quoniam Secundus
Taurominitanae ciuitatis episcopus no;^ actuum suorum in[g] no¬
centia confisus, sed superbae magis contumacia mentis elisus,
ecce iam transacto Deo propitio fere triennio, quod sedis aposto-
licae etsi indigni, tamen largiente et propitiante Deo, suscepimus
curam, ne dignatus quidem utrum uiueremus addiscere, sed causis
ac negotiis quibus sibi competit occupatus, remisso pudoris freno
uagari se credit, in tantum ut in sua[m] prope numquam inueniatur
fortasse elusus (?) 5 propiciante ex propiciente B 6 ne] ex nec B 8 se] posse add.
coni. Loewen. sua] Loewen.
Tit. Iohanni defensori: Ad quem ep. 44, p. 121, fuit item directa; for¬
te est idem defensor loannes de quo loquitur ep. 92,1, p. 219. His litteris
docemur eum in Sicilia defensoris munus obiisse.
^ 1. Secundus: Cf. P. Kwaed, c. o., l. c., p. 548, n. 2. Iterum ite-
rumque incusatur in epp. 78 et 79, p. 193-195.
Taurominitanus episcopus: Tauromenii, hodierna Taovmina, in
littore orientali Siciliae. Cf. F. Tanzoni. o. c., p. 616-624; G. Paeadino,
Taovmina, in Enc. Ital., t. XXXIII, p. 242-244.
iam transacto ... fere triennio: Consentiunt itaque et textus hic
et chronologia epistulae in Coli. Britannica, ubi prostat ante ep. 43, cuius
terminus ante quem est dies 22 martii a. 559. Memor esto Pelagium fuisse
probabiliter sacratum die 16 aprilis a. 556, ut monstravit cl. h. Duches-
NE, Vigile et Pilage ..., l. c., p. 428, n. 3.
uagari se credit: S. ToewenFEEd, o. c., p. 17, n. a, putavit pos¬
se fore addendum, non inmerito quidem. Sed cum credere vim habeat
interdum, quam denotant verba: se dare, se tradere, se committere, hisque
similia (cf. Thesaurus ..., t. IV, p. 1131-1133), absonum non videtur, sen¬
sum aliquem istius modi se credere hic habere. Ita et vis acutior sententiae,
ecclesia[m]; idcirco experientia tua pallium quidem ei ne utatur 2
omnimodis interdicat, ipsum etiam post diem sanctum pasc<h>ae,
ut nostris obtutibus praesentetur congrua executione conpellat,
quatinus disciplinam quam hucusque despexit, non solum ad suam
uerum etiam ad aliorum emendationem, conpetenti censura cog¬
noscat.
et cursus (si finis clausulae adsit) aut rhythmus servatur; aliter vero rhyth¬
mus ferme perimitur. Una difficultas ahcuius momenti est forte cons¬
tructio verbi cum modo infinitivo. Quod refert ad vitium vagandi in
episcopis, recole quod in Cone. Sardicensi a. 347, can. 8 (14) (11), praesu-
Hbus ecclesiarum fuit prohibitum, se a propriis ecclesiis plus quam tres
hebdomadas abesse. (C. H. Turner, Monumenta ..., t. I, ii, p. 474-477;
516-519; Manse t. III, c. 27-28; 36). Cf. quoque in ep. 5,7, p. 16, ad ver¬
bum formata.
2. post diem sanctum paschae: His aliquatenus roboratur prae¬
sumptio consecrationis pontificis in Pascha a. 556 (die 16 aprilis), nam anno
559 Paschae festum contigit die 13 aprilis. Cum hae litterae fuerint
conscriptae medio m. martio a. 559, recte dixit papa, iam fere transisse
triennium.
nostris obtutibus praesentetur... quatinus disciplinam: Episcopis
enim Romani patriarchatus incumbebat officium sese quotannis sistendi
coram papa, aut saltem quendam mittere legatum die consecrationis ponti¬
ficis. Cf. Lih. diurnus, form. 42-44; 74 (Th. E. V. SiCKEE, o. c., p. 31-32;
76-77); E. DuCHESNE, Le Lib. Pontif., t. I, p. CXXIX, 70; P. BaTiffoe, o.
c., p. 44. Quoad Siciliam S. GrEGORII Magne Peg., I, 39 (P. Ewaed, MGH.,
Epp., 1.1, p. 54, n. 5). Episcopus Taurominitanus suo defuerat officio, quo¬
circa voluit papa eidem, vel vi, faceret, satis. Attamen nullo modo id
praestitit, prout epp. 78 et 79 nos docent.
PEIyAGII I PAPAE
Defensori Opilio praecipit, ut coram Helpidio episcopo Catinensi
instituat presbyterum Maurum aut diaconum Cresciturum, abbatem
monasterii et nosocomii sancti loannis Catinae, atque omnem ordinandi
vel deponendi facultatem monachis interdicat
Revision history
- 2026-05-27v2.2.34-import
Initial corpus import from modern pelagius i retranslated v1.
Fields: letter text, metadata, source links. Source: https://archive.org/details/gasso-batlle-1956-pelagius
Related Letters
to God promissa are ualeant adimpleri.
To our honored friend and correspondent in the service of the Roman Emperor,
FELDy Epp, Pont, Rom, Ined,, 32, p, 17, PEEAGIUS AGNEEEO to the bishop.
We write to call you back to Rome, for we are both now old men, and the time remaining to us is uncertain.
Decr. Gratiani, X, 3, 10, c.